Comment on another love

  1. Ned canonically loved Catelyn so it's not weird that he'd act the same with this wife that he also loves. If you don't like a story just don't comment on it instead of being rude, it really is that simple.

    Comment Actions
    1. :D Thanks!

      Comment Actions
    2. Ned brought himself to love Catelyn after there marriage but here he married Ashara for love alone. There is a great difference between that.
      And how do you think Jon Arryn and Catelyn will settle for a second son. I mean if Jon had never wanted a strong alliance outside of his kingdom he would've gladly married his daughter to one of his banner men just like he'd done with his sister. What reason is there for him to agree for a match with a second son or a lesser lord of some other Kingdom. The Valemen is going to be pissed off at that. And Jon wanted a heir right. If it didn't worked with Ned he would tie with Robert. Even if his parentage is revealed there won't be much change. He is just a freaking bastard and after that he would be treated with hostility wherever he goes. So I hope that's not this story us going to be. If it did Ned is going to piss off not only Robert and Jon but his own northmen as well. I only thought about it now, has your plot happened before, in real. No I think not. Rickard betrothes his daughter outside his kingdom to a 'Great Lord' Hoster did the same. One instance I know of is Genna Lannister and Emmon Frey and that too made by her stupid father because Frey praised him. Look at how much Tywin was pissed off at that.

      Comment Actions
      1. I am aware... but Lyanna and Brandon and Rickard still died. Death and trauma changes people. Ned is subdued because of that, not because he doesn't love Ashara. She's been pretty bold and brash, and Ned hasn't complained. She rode out of Winterfell without even letting him know- she knows she can get away with a lot, because he adores her.

        Jon A and Cat aren't just going to settle. But notice how you are assuming all the characters are saying what they mean/telling the truth/being clear about their motivations. Why are you assuming that? Can't you just give it a chance? Maybe you should come back to this fic when its complete? Anon commenting is off now anyway, because of someone else.

        Comment Actions